BREAKING NEWS: Kelly Clarkson Goes Barefoot for Jim Gaffigan Interview – And He Has Something to Say.giang

Kelly Clarkson interviewed Jim Gaffigan without shoes — and the comedian had thoughts.

During the Tuesday, Jan. 7 episode of The Kelly Clarkson Show, Gaffigan, 58, called out Clarkson, 42, for showing up to the taping barefoot. “What is going on with the feet?” he asked while Clarkson tried to wish him a happy new year.

He then joked in a high-pitched voice about why Clarkson might be walking around without any shoes on. “I feel more grounded when I sing if I’m barefoot,” he mocked. “I can feel the ground.”

The American Idol alum laughed, agreeing with Gaffigan. “I do like performing barefoot, but that’s not why I’m barefoot,” she explained before getting into her relatable reason to kick off her shoes. “My feet hurt.”

“The stilettos I was supposed to wear today, I didn’t have enough middle fingers for it… so I just said no. I’ve never gone barefoot before, but that’s OK. That’s what we’re doing.”

Gaffigan, whose latest comedy special The Skinny dropped on Hulu in November, didn’t agree. “For me, first of all, I wouldn’t have my feet exposed because I respect the audience,” he said, to which Clarkson exclaimed “and I don’t.”

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

The Unfrosted actor didn’t stop there. He joked that there is a “portion of the internet” that will enjoy this episode featuring Clarkson sans shoes. But Clarkson was quick to respond, going toe-to-toe with his antics: “I’m gonna get a whole new fanbase.”

Clarkson has previously kicked off her shoes on her talk show for Kellyoke sessions “Quietly Yours” by Birdy and The Revivalists’ “It Was a Sin” in February 2024.

She’s also open to baring it all. In December, Clarkson boasted that she loves being naked. “Until gravity takes hold,” the “Since U Been Gone” singer clarified.

She’s not the only celebrity to go barefoot. In 2016, Julia Roberts attended the Cannes premiere of Money Monster without shoes. For New Year’s Eve, Cardi B performed barefoot at E11EVEN Miami.

The PEOPLE Puzzler crossword is here! How quickly can you solve it? Play now!

Kendall Jenner went to the Louvre in June and explored the Paris museum without anything on her feet. Angelina Jolie ditched her shoes during a December appearance on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon.